Play

Run, Don’t Walk: Five Below Has the Best Squishmallows Under $6

published Aug 2, 2023
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Black girl hugging teddy bear on sofa
Credit: JGI/Jamie Grill/Getty Images/Tetra images RF

They’re cuddly, they’re cute, and they’re collectible. It’s not hard to see why kids and adults alike are such big fans of Squishmallows — they’re basically like the beloved Beanie Babies of our past.

Quick Overview

Why should you shop at Five Below for Squishmallows?

Five Below has the cutest Squishmallows for under $6 — that’s way less expensive than you’d find anywhere else! These plush toys are super cuddly and endlessly collectible, almost like the Beanie Babies of our past.

There are so many different Squishmallows, and each one comes with a tag that provides a bit more information about the squishy toy. Tags typically include the Squishmallow’s name, birthday, and a bit of information about their past and personality. 

I’ve seen many of the larger Squishmallows cost $20 or even $30 in stores. But at Five Below, you don’t have to spend upwards of $20 a pop for these adorable plush toys. The discount chain has a large selection of Squishmallows in various designs and sizes, all online and in stores, and all under $6. Here are the best Squishmallows you can shop at Five Below.

1 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

The Foodie Squad Squishmallows might be my favorite, because who doesn’t want a squishy plush of their favorite food? This collection of 7.5-inch Squishmallows includes a chicken nugget, strawberry jam, a pineapple, cotton candy, a cookie, guacamole, a mango, and Hawaiian pizza.

2 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

Pick up a cuddly new stuffed animal from the Buddy Squad collection. Options include a guinea pig, a parakeet, a bulldog, a chameleon, a Siamese cat, a yellow snake, a koi fish, and a turtle. These 7.5-inch Squishmallows have fun features like a curly chameleon tail and a turtle shell.

3 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

Prehistoric creatures don’t have to be scaly and scary. In fact, they can be incredibly cute and cuddly! This Prehistoric Squishmallow line features a pterodactyl, a wooly mammoth, a dino, a sea dino, a T-rex, a saber-toothed tiger, a parasaurolophus, and a triceratops. The Prehistoric Squishmallows are 7.5 inches.

4 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

We’re big fans of the magical, yet somehow also real, narwhal in my house. If your kids are fans too, you can pick up a rainbow or purple tie-dye 7.5-inch narwhal Squishmallow. The rainbow narwhal, Ter, likes to relax with cucumber slices on its eyes and candles — a Squishmallow after my own heart.

5 / 10
Five Below
$5.00

If your kids like the excitement of opening a mystery bag, they’ll enjoy this Squooshems blind bag. Inside, they’ll find one of 10 small squishy figures. Squooshems are much smaller than the plush Squishmallow toys, and they feel similar to a stress ball.

6 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

Let a little fantasy into your home with the 7.5-inch Squshmallow Fantasy Squad line. Options include various dragons, bigfoot, a unicorn, a hippocorn, and a caticorn. I’m partial to the bigfoot one myself — look how cute it is!

7 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

Disney fans, rejoice! Five Below has six different 6.5-inch Lilo & Stitch Squishmallows, including one Lilo and five variations of Stitch. If you’ve always wanted a plush toy of Stitch dressed as Elvis or a pineapple, this one is just for you.

8 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

The whimsical wildlife Squishmallow line includes an owl, an antelope, a fox, a badger, a beaver, a moose, a raccoon, and a chipmunk, all at around 7.5 inches. Many of the wildlife creatures sport the most adorable tails on their back.

9 / 10
Five Below
$5.95

If your kids are ready to upgrade from friendship bracelets, then check out these friendship Squishmallows. Each 7.5-inch plush in this line has words written across its midsection like “best,” “friends,” “besties,” and “forever.” Styles include a bee, a ladybug, a cactus, an armadillo, a cow, a pig, a cheeseburger, and a french fry.

10 / 10
Five Below
$4.00

These teeny 3.5-inch Squishmallows are just the right size to clip onto a backpack or lunch box. The clip-on line includes a jellyfish, bigfoot, the Loch Ness monster, a turtle, a beetle, and a banana. Although they’re smaller than other Squishmallows, they’re still just as plush and cuddly.